Log in

Pay Dues |   Help  |  CLE Forms

Upcoming Zoom Event

Wednesday, October 14, 2020 @ 7:00 p.m.

Substantial Confusion:

The Ninth’s Circuit’s Approach to Early Dismissal of Literary Works Cases

With beaches, movie theaters and amusement parks closed for business, the Ninth Circuit spent its summer vacation deciding four substantial similarity cases involving The Shape of Water, Pirates of the Caribbean, Inside Out and Empire.  In unpublished opinions, the Court affirmed early dismissals in two of the cases, but reversed in the other two, leaving copyright lawyers and district court judges trying to make sense of it all.

On October 14, the Los Angeles Copyright Society will host a panel of experts who will explore the Ninth Circuit’s approach to substantial similarity, tackling such issues as when lawsuits can be dismissed prior to discovery, the role of expert witnesses, and the process district court judges may use to decide these cases going forward. 

We’ll be joined by Elaine Kim, partner at Mitchell Silberberg who’s represented defendants in many substantial similarity matters, as well as Peter Afrasiabi, partner at One LLP who’s handled these cases on the plaintiffs’ side.  Moderating the panel will be LACS immediate past president Aaron Moss, who chairs the litigation department at Greenberg Glusker and has covered these cases for his blog Copyright Lately.

Register here.


Elaine Kim


Peter Afrasiabi


 Aaron Moss





Catherine Bridge
The Walt Disney Company

Joel Tantalo


Tantalo & Adler LLP

Andrew J. Thomas
Vice President
Jenner & Block

Vivian S. Lee

The Walt Disney Company

Dan Nabel
Riot Games


Peter Anderson
Davis Wright Tremaine LLP

Jacqueline Charlesworth

Alter, Kendrick & Baron LLP

Daniel M. Flores

Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios Inc.

Jamie Frieden

Frieden Wolf Law

Caroline Mankey
Akerman LLP

Jennifer E. Rothman

LMU Loyola Law School

Ben Sheffner

Motion Picture Association, Inc.

Ian Slotin

John Ulin

Immediate Past President

Aaron Moss
Greenberg Glusker

© 2020 Los Angeles Copyright Society | All Rights Reserved 

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software